The pie case

Pie menu

Pie availability changes with the season and what is coming out of the oven. If you do not see what you are looking for, include it in your order request.

A golden lattice-topped fruit pie displayed inside Anita’s Pie Shop.

Prices

Whole pie: Fruit$22Specialty$26
5-inch personal pie: Fruit$10Specialty$12
Hand pie: Fruit$7Specialty$7
Slice: Fruit$5Specialty—

Published prices by format
Format	Fruit	Specialty
Whole pie	$22	$26
5-inch personal pie	$10	$12
Hand pie	$7	$7
Slice	$5	—

Fruit pies

Peach
Cherry
Apricot
Apple
Blueberry
Triple Berry
Strawberry
Rhubarb
Cranberry

A whole cream pie with a piped topping, chocolate and caramel drizzle, almonds and chocolate chips.

House creations

White Chocolate Almond Peach
Blueberry Peach
Strawberry Rhubarb
Caramel Apple
Cranberry Apple Walnut
Blueberry Cherry
Triple Berry Peach
Double Chocolate Cherry
Cranberry Apple
Caramel Apple Pecan
Strawberry Peach
Cherry Peach

Specialty pies

Seasonal availability.

Coconut Cream
Chocolate Cream
Key Lime
Pumpkin
Pecan

Cheesecakes & Specialty Cakes

Plain Cheesecake
Cherry Crumble Cheesecake
Peach Crumble Cheesecake
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Cinnamon Cheesecake
Chocolate Cheesecake

6-inch cheesecake: $15
9-inch cheesecake: $26

New York–Style Cheesecake — $9.99/lb.

Available to request in a 6-inch or 9-inch size.

Pecan Specialty

5-inch Pecan Specialty: $15
9-inch Pecan Specialty: $26

Peach-topped cheesecake prepared at Anita’s Pie Shop.

Savory Pot Pies

Beef Pot PieAvailable year-round
Chicken Pot PieAvailable year-round
Turkey Pot PieSeasonal: available from Thanksgiving through Christmas

9-inch savory pot pie: $40
5-inch personal savory pot pie: $15

Breakfast Pies

Breakfast Pie

9-inch Breakfast Pie — $40
5-inch Breakfast Pie — $15

Found your pie?

Send a request with what you would like and when you would like to pick it up.

Request a Pie

Submitting a request does not reserve your order. Your order is confirmed only after you hear back from Anita’s Pie Shop. No payment is collected online.